Which is the best 3D smartphone?
|
HTC EVO 3D |
|
LG OPTIMUS 3D |
LG announced the world’s first 3D glasses-less handset but now HTC is aiming to muscle into 3D territory, but which handset will emerge as king of 3D phones?
Form
LG Optimus 3D - 128.8 x 68 x 11.9 mm, 168g
HTC EVO 3D - 126 x 65 x 12.1 mm, 170g
At first glance these phones have a lot of similarities, despite coming from different manufacturers, they seem to be following in Samsung’s footsteps with the Galaxy S II of going for thinner, longer and more angular ‘card-like’ phones and we think this can only be a good thing.
There is one visual element which we feel the both phones have tripped up on though and that is the back panel and camera integration.
These 3D handsets use a dual camera setup to capture stereoscopic images and LG have opted for a fairly chunky metal bar on the back panel of the Optimus to seat the cameras in and which has ‘3D Stereoscope’ etched into it.
HTC’s arrangement is far more subtle and looks all the better for it, integrating well with the sleek design of the rest of the handset and maintaining the low profile look.
However, HTC have compromised this by incorporating a rather ugly silver swirly crossbar design into the whole back panel of the phone with the Google logo etched into the middle of it – if it weren’t for this the HTC would be far superior visually but as it stands, while they are both good looking phones from the front, there is nothing praiseworthy about either at the rear.
Winner - Draw
Display
HTC’s newcomer, the Evo 3D, has a 4.3-inch capacitive LCD touchscreen running at 540 x 960 resolution.
The Evo features multi-touch input, accelerometer and gyro and the HTC Sense user interface (UI).
LG’s Optimus 3D also has a 4.3-inch capacitive LCD touchscreen, this one is at 480 x 800 resolution and uses the LG 3D UI, there's no multi-touch on the Optimus 3D but it does have the usual accelerometer and gyro sensors.
There’s not much between these two but we feel the HTC just steps ahead with its higher resolution screen and additional features such as multi-touch.
Winner- HTC Evo 3D
Operating System
Both phones are Android based, the Evo 3D uses the latest smartphone build, 2.3 Gingerbread, while the Optimus 3D currently ships with 2.2 Froyo, it is, however, due to receive an upgrade to 2.3 in the not-too-distant future.
Gingerbread is a good choice for both these handsets as their hefty processing power will let them get the best out of the efficient multitasking and customisation on offer, they should both be able to run the operating system very smoothly.
Gingerbread isn’t optimised for the dual-core processors these handsets have but future versions of Android might be and it would be interesting to see how this could improve performance and efficiency with these two phones.
ProcessorThe Optimus 3D has a 1GHz dual-core ARM Cortex-A9 processor running the TI OMAP4430 chipset and featuring a PowerVR SGX540 graphics processing unit (GPU).
HTC, meanwhile, has opted for a 1.2 GHz Qualcomm MSM8660 dual-core processor on the Snapdragon chipset and with an Adreno 220 GPU.
The Evo 3D has the better of the two processor setups here, the Cortex-A9 in the Optimus is a brilliant piece of kit but these new Snapdragon processors really are something else.
Winner – HTC Evo 3D